Sixteen People Arrested on Federal Indictment Involving Multi-State Car Theft Conspiracy

U.S. Attorney’s Office, Eastern District of Missouri
April 23, 2013

ST. LOUIS, MO—Sixteen people have been arrested on a federal indictment charging 21 defendants involved in a multi-state car theft conspiracy. The conspiracy is alleged to have utilized several different schemes to steal and misappropriate vehicles, commit bank fraud in order to obtain vehicles, and obtain insurance proceeds by staging accidents and filing false theft reports.

The indictment alleges that the defendants stole luxury automobiles, sports utility vehicles, and pickup trucks from individuals and automobile dealerships in the Eastern District of Missouri, Iowa, Illinois, and Indiana, vehicles that they transported to the Eastern District of Missouri. They disabled any tracking systems, like OnStar, on the stolen vehicles so that they could not be traced by law enforcement.

In addition, it is charged that the defendants themselves, or “straw” purchasers, made false statements on loan applications and submitted fraudulent earnings statements in support to obtain loans to purchase typically high-end vehicles. The defendants used and then sold or disposed of the vehicles, while the loan defaulted, either immediately or after a short payment history. According to the indictment, the defendants also practiced fraud related to the titling of vehicles, obtaining by false statements apparently legitimate ownership to vehicles they had stolen from individuals. On many occasions, the defendants falsely claimed to have done repair work that was not actually performed on vehicles submitted to their businesses, inducing lien holders to pay the defendants money to avoid the issuance of a mechanics lien. More than 100 vehicles have been fully identified as being involved in the criminal activity, although investigators believe many more were actually involved.

Arrested today:

Shahadu Sutton, 38, St. Louis
Tiffany Sutton, 38, St. Louis
Orlando Preston, 38, St. Louis
William Smith, 48, Highland, Kansas
Robert Reece, 40, St. Louis
John Hicks, 30, St. Louis
Reginald Davis, 30, Florissant, Missouri
Steven Pirtle, 45, St. Louis
Sheldon Mitchell, 42, Ballwin, Missouri
Chester Wilson, 41, St. Louis
Arvis Dunbar, 47, St. Louis
Eugene Dunbar, 63, St. Louis
Michael Smith, 40, Florissant, Missouri
Terrelle Marion, 46, Florissant, Missouri
Jermaine Gamble, 32, in custody
Joseph Pearson, 38, St. Louis area

Charges include conspiracy, bank fraud, mail fraud, and receipt of stolen motor vehicle. If convicted, these charges carry penalties ranging from five to 30 years in prison and/or fines up to $1,000,000. In determining the actual sentences, a judge is required to consider the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines, which provide recommended sentencing ranges.

This case was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, United States Postal Inspection Service, St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department, St. Louis County Police Department, Missouri State Highway Patrol, Maplewood Police Department, Missouri Department of Revenue, and other municipal police departments, with assistance from the National Insurance Crime Bureau. Assistant United States Attorneys John Ware and Stephen Casey are handling the case for the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

As is always the case, charges set forth in an indictment are merely accusations and do not constitute proof of guilt. Every defendant is presumed to be innocent unless and until proven guilty.